Jay Fergusonjay@deepcreekvacations.com301-501-0420
Menu

In letter, county leaders express frustration with board of education

Elaine Blaisdell

Cumberland Times-News

— OAKLAND — In an open letter to the Garrett County Board of Education, the Garrett County commissioners expressed their frustration over being placed in a collective bargaining negotiation process with the public school system.

“It was you, the board of education, who negotiated a salary increase only to then make anincrease in employee compensation a controversial segment of the county government fiscal year 2015 budget,” says the letter addressed to Thomas Carr, president of the board. “It would seem from a responsibility perspective that you would honor the agreement you negotiated by eliminating items within the approved 2015 Board of Education budget.”

Carr said that reopening the negotiations would be the worstcase scenario.

“We have gone through a lot of choices and a lot of the cuts, that is not part of what is being considered. Since the letter went out we would really like to know where the written notification required by law is stating that we are anticipating reopening negotiations,” said Carr during Tuesday’s county commission meeting.

Larry McKenzie, director of finance for the board, questioned the accuracy of some of the facts contained in the letter.

“There are certain half truths within the letter,” said McKenzie.

McKenzie agreed that the board’s budget had increased to $51.8 million in fiscal 2015 compared to $51.3 million in fiscal 2014.

“I would say, by the same token, that we’ve made cuts and adjustments,” said McKenzie.

Cuts have been made to positions and the budget includes capital items such as the Southern Middle School renovation project, the alternative education program, textbooks and computers, according to McKenzie. The renovation project could potentially cost $16 million, according to the letter.

“Yes, we show a budget increase but certainly it’s not haphazard in terms of how those funds are being spent and certainly they are needs of the school system and needs of Garrett County,” said McKenzie.

Garrett school board looking to expand advocacy committee

Elaine BlaisdellCumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — The Garrett County Board of Education is looking for new members to join the Advocacy Committee, which will include high and middle school students.

“What I would like to do is find out the interest for those people who were originally appointed to the advisories, those who would like to stay on to do some planning on behalf of the school system,” said Superintendent Janet Wilson.

Those wishing to be on the committee will be required to fill out a new application because the scope of the group has changed since the board halted a plan to close three elementary  schools. The board was required to keep the schools open as one of the conditions of the county commissioners’ decision to give the board $2.2 million.

The Advocacy Committee has to have “a manageable number of members” with one from each school, according to Wilson. Board members will also be present at the Advocacy Committee meetings.

Paul Swanson of Facility Engineering Associates, who is the author of the facilities study, and Mike Gehr, of Bushey Feight Morin Architects Inc., met with the Advocacy Committee on Monday and answered 162 questions, about 90 of which pertained to the facilities study, according to William Swift, director of maintenance and operations with Garrett County Public Schools.

Board member Rodney Reckart discussed the renovation of Southern Middle School and said funding for it “has been nightmare” and that the state won’t pay for 20 percent of the construction costs. Reckart asked Gehr if it would be more cost effective to raze part of the building. Gehr said taking off square footage may not be in the best interest and indicated there were other options to explore.

In July, the commissioners voted to defer the $582,400 renovation for one year.

More here.

Garrett to hear results of school study

From Staff Reports

Cumberland Times-News

MCHENRY — Facility Engineering Associates, P.C. will share the results of the elementary school facility needs assessment and master plan study for Garrett County Public Schools in a public meeting Oct. 28 at 7 p.m. in the Community Aquatic and Recreation Complex at Garrett College.

FEA was engaged by the school system to provide an in-depth study to provide information on the best options to cost-effectively meet the instructional needs of the students in the county. In three years, declines in revenue and student enrollment have brought about reductions in the work force, the closure of three schools and the elimination of programs, according to a news release. Dennett Road and Kitzmiller elementary schools closed last year as a cost-cutting measure and Bloomington Elementary was closed in 2011.

The school system estimates losses of $1.5 million for fiscal 2015 due to the state’s wealth formula which is, in part, based on enrollment.

The school system will not have available $700,000 that was received from a legislative hold harmless initiative used to balance the current year’s budget, according to the news release.

Sen. George Edwards recently wrote to Gov. Martin O’Malley requesting him to put in an administration bill, support one that Edwards puts in or request through the budget process to hold counties harmless from losing any money until a new wealth formula is complete. The wealth formula will be looked at in the fall of 2014 and won’t be included until 2016.

If O’Malley doesn’t provide emergency action, process for school closures will begin in the fall, Edwards said.

Given the financial challenges ahead of the school system, the results of the study will provide data to help identify short- and long- term facility plans to meet the needs of the students enrolled in the school system, according to the Garrett County Board of Education.

The scope of the study includes the assessment of elements required by the Code of Maryland Regulations, which governs school closings should the board vote to move in that direction.

More here.

Garrett commission keeps school renovation project

Elaine Blaisdell Cumberland Times-News

CUMBERLAND — OAKLAND — The Garrett County commissioners voted Tuesday to allow $582,400 for the design phase of the Southern Middle School Renovation Project to remain intact in the fiscal 2014 budget with the condition that no funds will be spent until further discussion with the board of education. They also approved the fiscal 2014 budget.

“At the present time, the $582,400 will remain in the budget as part of the capital outlay for the board of education and earmarked for the Southern Middle School Renovation Project design,” said Monty Pagenhardt, county administrator.

The decision to expend the design’s fund money or to remove it altogether from the budget will be made upon mutual agreement between the commissioners and the board of education, officials said.

In a letter to Superintendent Janet Wilson, Pagenhardt requested that the board delay any request for proposals or bid preparations for the design and planning until the commissioners and board conduct a public session on public school funding.

“As in the past … commissioners will be presented with a draft Capital Improvement Plan by the board of education in September or October,” said Pagenhardt in the letter.

“I would also ask that this review and approval include a possible deferral of the Southern Middle School project, be finalized prior to any architectural design funding is solicited by the BOE,” he said.

The estimated debt service obligation to the county for Southern Middle School is $750,000 per year for 30 years, according to Pagenhardt.

“Commitment of the debt is a decision that requires more review and evaluation,” said Pagenhardt in the letter.

The fiscal 2015 funding request for the board of education includes an estimated $5.1 million increase.

“If the county were to fund the BOE at the level that is shown, the combination of any new revenue generated from any revenue source or any increase in the real property tax rate would be obligated to the public school system,” said Pagenhardt. “All other departments would need to be reduced or flat funded.”

In past years, major board of education capital projects have been moved to future budget years due to planned funding shortfalls, according to Pagenhardt.

Commissioner Gregan Crawford initially made a motion to exclude funding for the project, which he later rescinded.

Commissioner Jim Raley wanted to proceed with leaving the project in the budget but to discuss with the board of education the possibility of completing the project in phases.

“We just made room in the budget to hire three school resource officers to keep our children safe,” said Raley during the commission meeting. “It’s easy to say this justifies raising taxes, but when does it end? Let’s pull together and pray our work is making a difference.”

Contact Elaine Blaisdell at eblaisdell@times-news.com.

More here.

Education to take lion’s share of Garrett budget

Despite being fully funded, board predicts a bleak forecast for next few years

Elaine Blaisdell Cumberland Times-News   The Cumberland Times-News       Thu May 09, 2013, 11:46 PM EDT

OAKLAND — The largest appropriation in Garrett County’s proposed fiscal 2014 budget is $32.3 million for public education, or 41 percent of the total Operating and Capital Budget for fiscal year 2014, according to Monty Pagenhardt, county administrator.
The county is proposing to allot $26.2 million to the board of education for fiscal 2014. The remainder of the public education funding goes to Garrett College, the Ruth Enlow Library and the Garrett County Scholarship Program.
“The board of education was informed in May of 2012 of this funding level,” said Pagenhardt. “The BOE budget for 2014 is fully funded.” The board was alloted $26 million for fiscal 2013.
Despite being fully funded for fiscal 2014, the board is predicting a bleak financial forecast for the next couple of years, according to a letter from the board to citizens.
Superintendent Janet Wilson, Pagenhardt and respective staff will attempt to develop cooperative points of interest regarding the budget and set up a meeting at a later date.
“County government has for some time reviewed current budgets along with five impending years, and this practice has proven to be a wise judgment, which is evident when comparing actual/final budgets to initial budget estimates,” said Pagenhardt in response to the board’s letter.
“County government and the Board of County Commissioners have made public education a priority for many years. Now, more than ever, open dialog and cooperation, to include the participation of the county administrator, superintendent of schools, and senior staff from both our organizations, is imperative.”
The real property tax rate for fiscal 2014 will be the same as 2013 at $0.9900, according to Pagenhardt.
During the public informational meeting Wednesday, the public questioned Adventure Sports Center International funding and asked questions that were under the authority of the elected board of education, according to Pagenhardt. Four elected board members were in attendance but didn’t speak or provide commentary, said Pagenhardt. Wilson was not in attendance.
The expenditure for ASCI debt repayment for fiscal 2014 is $100,000 to be paid out of hotel rental tax. In March of last year, the county took ownership of ASCI, paying $600,000 to secure the assignment of ASCI debts from Susquehanna Bank.
The fiscal 2014 budget is recommending $1.7 million for Deep Creek 2014 capital improvements to ASCI. The ASCI capital improvements are completely funded by grants.
Total budget for fiscal 2014 is $78.3 million, which is $4.4 million less than the fiscal 2013 budget of $82.7 million. Capital projects and outlay make up $2.6 million of the $4.4 million, according to Pagenhardt.
The fiscal 2014 budget includes $2.2 million from the unreserved/undesignated fund balance (reserves restricted for planned capital expenditures).
“No reserves are used for operating expenses,” said Pagenhardt.
Pagenhardt doesn’t expect changes to the fiscal 2014 budget for now.
“There will be amendments to fiscal year 2013 budget when we have actual revenue or expenditures,” said Pagenhardt. “Final adjustments to the fiscal year budget come with the audit.”
The county commissioners will approve the budget during the June 4 public meeting.
The budget, in its entirety, can be viewed at  www.garrettcounty.org.
Contact Elaine Blaisdell at eblaisdell@times-news.com.

Garrett board of education warns of bleak times ahead

Garrett board of education warns of bleak times ahead

Between 2009 and 2014, state aid dropped $4.5 million

From Staff Reports Cumberland Times-News   The Cumberland Times-News       Tue May 07, 2013, 11:15 PM EDT

CUMBERLAND — OAKLAND —  The Garrett County Board of Education posted an open letter to citizens on its website to alert them that the financial forecast for the next couple of years looks bleak.
The board adopted Superintendent Janet Wilson’s fiscal  2014 budget during a special meeting April 18. During that meeting, projections relating to the anticipated fiscal 2015 revenue and 2016 revenue shortfalls were shared.
Garrett County Public Schools receives more than 90 percent of its revenue from state and local sources.
State revenues have continued to decline in recent years as a result of the county’s increasing wealth and the school system’s declining enrollment.
Between fiscal years 2009 and 2014, revenues from state aid have declined by more than $4.5 million, while corresponding aid from county government has increased by $2.2 million.
Last year, Dennett Road and Kitzmiller elementary schools closed permanently because of a $2 million shortfall, and other programs were cut.
The decision was made to close the schools despite receiving $500,000 from the county commissioners.
Bloomington Elementary was closed in 2011.
“Last-minute funding offered by the Board of County Commissioners came with no promises of future funding which would have required the advisory group process, and the emotional turmoil that goes with the process, to be repeated the following year,” said the letter.
If reliable and sustainable streams of revenue cannot be identified and committed in a timely manner for fiscal 15 and beyond, the school system is required by state code to begin the advisory process to determine if school closures, consolidation and redistricting are necessary, according to the letter.
“This time, every school (all eight in the county) will be involved in the process requiring that the advisory meetings begin this summer,” said the letter.
The school board will obtain a facility study and the results will be given to the advisory committees.
The study will be conducted on Accident, Broad Ford, Crellin, Friendsville, Grants-ville, Route 40, Swan Meadow and Yough Glades Elementary schools.
The results of the study will help to ensure that the best decisions regarding any school closures, consolidation and redistricting are made for 2015 and for the future of the county schools. Decisions regarding closures, consolidation and redistricting for fiscal 2015 must be made by April 1, 2014.
In fiscal year 2015, the board anticipates that the state aid revenues will decline by an additional $1 million.
The board invited commissioners to discuss the future of the Garrett County Public School System on April 24, but the commissioners couldn’t attend because the meeting precludes the final approval of the county’s fiscal 2014 budget, which will be adopted at the June 4 public meeting.
“Public education is certainly a priority for the county and the identification of long-term financial planning has been and will continue to be a high priority,” said Monty Pagenhardt, county administrator. “Just as the public school system is experiencing a reduction of funding, all other county government core areas of public interest must be cognizant of the current economic times.”
The board has no revenue-generating authority and is squarely dependent on the commissioners’ commitment to providing an adequate operating budget, according to the letter.
The county is proposing to allot $26.2 million to public school system for fiscal 2014, according to Pagenhardt. The largest portion of the county’s fiscal 2013 budget allotted $26,023,714 to the board.
Without additional aid from the commissioners, the approximate fiscal 2015 budget gap for the board would be $1.7 million, according to the letter.
Projections indicate that in fiscal 2016, the school system faces an additional $450,000 deficit.
“The local share of the current county government’s budget does not represent an adequate amount to operate our school system and has not been adequate for some time,” states the letter.
The commissioners will conduct an informational budget meeting today at 7 p.m. at Garrett College auditorium.
“It is our hope that the fiscal 2014 budget discussion will include a promise of revenue that will secure the future of the school system in fiscal 2015,” said the letter. “Without guaranteed streams of funding and with the additional requirements of reform focusing on massive change at the classroom level, there will be consequences.”
The board needs a committed amount of revenue for 2015 and beyond in order to avert the need for school closure, consolidation and redistricting advisory meetings and to plan for instructional programs necessary for current reforms, according to the letter.
Wilson, Pagenhardt and respective staff will get together to develop cooperative points of interest regarding the budget and set up a meeting at a later date.
The letter can be read in its entirety at http://www. ga.k12.md.us/. The county budget can be viewed at www.garrettcounty.org.

 

Schools’ chief recommends denial of charter application

Riverside Academy would increase financial burden on school system

Elaine Blaisdell Cumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — Garrett County Superintendent of Schools Janet Wilson is recommending that the Board of Education deny an application for a proposed charter school in Kitzmiller. Six committees reviewed the application submitted by Kitzmiller Charter School Initiative Inc. and, for the most part, the analysis of the application yielded unfavorable recommendations, ac-cording to Wilson’s recommendation.

“I concur with the analysis and subsequent recommendations made by members of the six review committees,” Wilson wrote in her recommendation “Although my recommendation to deny the charter school application could stand alone, the addendum to this recommendation also ad-dresses the fiscal implications of granting the charter application during a period of declining student enrollment and unprecedented financial hardships for the Garrett County Public Schools.”

Wilson noted that granting the application for Riverside Academy would increase the financial burden on the school system as a whole and would result in the need of further school closings, student redistricting, reductions in force of staff and the continued inability to meet negotiated employee pay scales.

“What is clear and compelling is that there will be a significant impact to all Garrett County public schools and all students should Riverside Academy become a reality,” wrote Wilson.

Under Maryland law, a county board of education must fund a public charter school with an amount “that is commensurate with the amount disbursed to other public schools in the local jurisdiction,” according to the state Department of Education.

The doors to Dennett Road and Kitzmiller Elementary closed permanently in May of last year and Bloomington Elementary closed in 2011.

“These closures represent 20 percent of the 15 schools that served Garrett County in fiscal 2011,” Wilson wrote. “These closures, as well as corresponding reductions in force and other significant reductions or eliminations of programs, while painstakingly difficult for the elected Board of Education, were necessary to ensure the ability of the Board to continue to meet its obligations of providing a free quality education program to all children of Garrett County.”

The closing of Dennett Road and Kitzmiller elementary schools saved about $1 million and $279,000, respectively, helping to close a shortfall of $2 million.

The school board will vote on Wilson’s recommendation during a special meeting on Thursday at 7 p.m. at Southern Middle School.

To read the recommendation in it’s entirety, visit the BOE website at www.ga.k12. md.us.

Contact Elaine Blaisdell at eblaisdell@times-news.com.