Jay Fergusonjay@deepcreekvacations.com301-501-0420
Menu

Commission candidates weigh in on biggest issues facing Garrett County

Elaine Blaisdell

Cumberland Times-News

— OAKLAND — Garrett County Commission candidates for District 2, Paul Edwards, Tim Thomas, incumbent Jim Raley and Gary Barlow address the biggest issues that the county is facing.

Edwards said the lack of quality economic development is the biggest issue.

“The only thing I can do to address that is to point to the track record in Grantsville, which has been the fastest-growing town in the county,” said Edwards, Grantsville mayor. The town will welcome 10 new businesses this year. “We’ve been able to do that by working together with community business, state and local officials, creating a financial climate that is conducive to businesses.”

Thomas said the county needs to grow economically by 1 percent to 3 percent a year.

“We can do this by creating the opportunities for companies to move into the county,” said Thomas. “We need to be working on programs that will help with lowering property taxes to entice the primary home market as well as the secondary market, too.”

Grantsville has the lowest tax and utility rates around, according to Edwards.

“We have a target marketing campaign for businesses that fit and it’s been very successful for us. It’s something we can take countywide,” said Edwards.

Thomas said the biggest issue is the lack of good quality jobs.

“I strongly believe that we need to get proactive about jobs that will support a family environment, allowing the communities to grow, our tax base to grow and preventing a raise in taxes,” said Thomas.

Thomas, Raley and Barlow are in agreement that budgetary issues are also important.

“Our budget is underfunded, causing a shortfall for many programs, like education, road maintenance and overall growth to name a few,” said Thomas.

The county’s budget issues stem from the state passing down more costs, like the loss in highway user funds and the costs associated with the teacher pension passback, to the locals, according to Raley. In addition to budgetary concerns, young families are leaving the area due to lack of jobs that provide a living wage, said Raley.

“We have got to grow our economy and our tax base, and the best way to do that is to bring in more young families,” said Raley.

The Friendsville revitalization project, which is aimed at drawing young families into the area, could be used in other towns throughout the county, said Raley. Friends-ville has the capacity to become a millennial community because of its community trails and other amenities, said Raley. In October, the commission voted to allot $25,000 for design concept drawings to revitalize the town.

Barlow said that the biggest issue the county is facing is the funding of the schools.

“I do not believe enough good jobs or, more importantly, enough families with children will move to Garrett County to save our schools,” said Barlow. “Our problem is not that we don’t collect enough taxes, it is that we are not managing the amount we collect. Our operating costs are too high,” said Barlow.

Barlow said that the board of education increased costs by hiring unnecessary employees and by giving generous retirement health care benefits along with retiree supplemental insurance during a time when tax revenue and funding was strong.

“These benefits are better than state and federal workers, not to mention most private employees get no health benefits upon retirement. Instead of planning for our kids’ future, they planned their own future,” said Barlow. “Instead of combing schools on the east side of the county and building one in a more centralized location to serve those communities.”

The board has doubled administrative costs from $1.3 million in 2009 to $2.6 million in 2013, with almost $700,000 in one year, according to Barlow.

In December, the commissioners voted to give the board $2.2 million for fiscal 2015.

“The current commissioners took money from an account supposed to fund the retirement health care benefits so the schools could remain open,” said Barlow. “It just happens to fund the schools past the election. I believe the residents of Garrett County are already set up for a tax increase to fund the schools in 2016.”

Barlow vows to end the pensions for the commissioners office only.

“My opponents seem to think that asking people who don’t have pensions to pay for theirs is somehow all right. Keep in mind two of them already have taxpayer-fund pensions; they would like a second. Commissioner Raley’s actions have given us many problems,” said Barlow. “I don’t see Paul Edwards standing up to his direct boss, the superintendent of the schools, or fixing our operation costs. But if you feel compelled to vote for him and his lofty plans don’t work, then what will he do?”

Both Edwards and Raley said that people should vote for them because of their experience in local government. Edwards has 15 years in municipal government in Grantsville and Raley has been on the commission for four years and served on the board of education for 14 years.

“I have a record of accomplishments and experience that I can point to. I have a track record of working with people and sitting down at the table to solve problems,” said Edwards.

Raley said that he is committed to giving people a seat at the table even if their opinion differs from his.

“Under my administration everyone has a seat at the table and everyone’s opinions matter,” said Raley.

Raley said that he has knowledge of how the two biggest budgets — county and school — work.

“I demonstrate a good knowledge of what needs to be done in the county. We have a more open, transparent and honest government than we have ever had in the past,” said Raley. “I am a full-time commissioner and I have no conflicts that some of the other candidates may have because of their ties to other organizations.”

Thomas said that his experience operating his own company for the past 18 years gives him a unique business sense for solving problems.

“I am very outgoing, energetic and willing to work out the problems and solve the issues that are affecting our county,” said Thomas. “I believe it’s time that we work to save what so many have come to call our family, our friends, our home — Garrett County.”

Contact Elaine Blaisdell at eblaisdell@times-news.com.

More here.

Garrett school system asks commissioners for funding bump

Elaine Blaisdell

Cumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — The Garrett County Public School system is requesting $26,179,897 from the county for fiscal 2015, according to a budget presentation made by Larry McKenzie, director of finance.

The funding request is $820,897 more than the prior year’s request. The additional funding is needed to pay a portion of the costs associated with the teacher pension passback, which increased to more than $1 million, McKenzie said during a county commission meeting Tuesday.

“Since I’ve been here I have been accused of running the school system like a business — actually it is,” said Superintendent of Schools Janet Wilson. “It has to be run that way with our bottom line being very different.”

Capital requests include $582,400 for the design phase of the Southern Middle School renovation project, which is set to begin next year. In January, the commissioners approved the money for the design phase. The renovation will include a performing arts venue, a third of which will fit in the original footprint of the building, according to Wilson.

“This would be for a facility that looks like Mountain Ridge’s (performing arts venue) in terms of its size,” said Wilson.

Mountain Ridge has the capacity to seat 500 and is 9,000 square feet, according to Bill Swift, director of facilities, maintenance and operations at GCPS.

“We are the only county in the state that does not have a performing arts center,” said Swift.

Capital requests also include $415,000 for the Dennett Road maintenance pole building and $213,000 for lighting projects at several middle schools.

“It’s important to understand that $213,000 and the $582,400 were basically appropriated for in fiscal ’14,” said McKenzie. “Those aren’t really new requests.”

Aging Schools and Qualified Zone Academy Bond funds have been appropriated in the fiscal 2015 budget for several school-based maintenance and operations projects. The school system has applied for and received QZAB funds, according to McKenzie.

Funding sources include 54.25 percent local, 39.08 percent state, 6.33 percent federal and 0.34 percent miscellaneous funding. The 54 percent local puts the county over the maintenance of effort, which requires that the level of state and local funding remain relatively constant from year to year, according to Commissioner Gregan Crawford. The school system expects to receive $19,254,093 in state aid, which is similar to the amount received in 2005, according to McKenzie.

Locally, the county has increased funding to almost $8 million since 2005, according to Commissioner Jim Raley.

Contact Elaine Blaisdell at eblaisdell@times-news.com.

More here.

Garrett commissioners don’t expect rafting complex to be county operation for long term

Elaine Blaisdell

Cumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — Garrett County commissioners recently met with the grand jury and indicated that they didn’t believe that it was in their best interest for Adventure Sports Center International in McHenry to remain a county operation in the long term. Commissioner Jim Raley indicated in an interview with the Times-News that he would like to see the manmade whitewater rafting complex run on a lease basis.

If an entity were to take ownership of ASCI it wouldn’t happen until sometime after Deep Creek 2014: International Canoe Federation Canoe Slalom World Championships, which are scheduled for September, according to Raley.

Commissioner Gregan Crawford said that the county doesn’t own ASCI, but that they bought out the bank notes and is ASCI’s largest creditor.

“ASCI was a situation that was really more thrust on us. We didn’t go out and look for it,” said Crawford.

In 2012, the commissioners authorized the expenditure of $600,000 to secure the assignment of ASCI debts from Susquehanna Bank. The original debt for ASCI was $3 million, according to Chairman Robert Gatto.

“When you look at the capital investment that was made, by not only the county taxpayers but the state and some federal monies that went into the project, it had to be stabilized,” said Raley.

Crawford echoed Raley’s sentiments, noting that one of the reasons for keeping ASCI in the short term was the need to stabilize it.

“We hope to polish it up and have everything in place,” said Crawford.

ASCI is funded by multiple sources, such as federal, state and community development block grants. It is still operating in the black, has been for the past two years and sees 10,000 to 11,000 visitors per year, according to Raley. ASCI runs like an enterprise fund on revenues it brings in, similar to the county landfill, according to Crawford.

The county cut costs by looking into the number of personnel and making sure that the water was turned off when it wasn’t needed, said Raley. ASCI has 65 to 70 seasonal (May through September) employees at a cost of $267,000.

Crawford stressed the importance of Deep Creek 2014 and its future economic impact on the county.

Garrett County was awarded $1 million from the state’s capital budget for upgrades to ASCI in preparation for Deep Creek 2014. The state bond proceeds will partially fund the $2.3 million in improvements, which include design, construction, repair, renovation, reconstruction and capital equipping of ASCI. The project will also include upgrading telecommunications and building new and upgrading existing infrastructure and facilities. United States Department of Agriculture grants, Maryland Heritage Area grants and a local access grant from the Appalachian Regional Commission will be used toward improvements, Crawford said.

An earthen amphitheater with concrete masonry walls, an open pavilion and a viewing platform will be built for the event, according to the county’s website.

An access road bridge for Deep Creek 2014 might not be ready for the event, according to Dwight Emory, P.E., director of the Garett County engineering department. The rest of the improvements are expected to be completed on time.

The event is expected to draw 35 to 40 international teams; 1,200 coaches, athletes and support staff; 30,000 spectators and is estimated to have a more than $20 million economic impact on Garrett County.

“One of the goals of 2014 is to make it (ASCI) an epicenter for adventure sports, not only on the East Coast but throughout the United States as well,” said Crawford.

Gatto said that timing of Deep Creek 2014 will help bolster the economy at a time when there is a seasonal lull.

More here.

Garrett ethics board dismisses complaint against county commissioner

From Staff ReportsCumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — The Garrett County Ethics Commission recently met and decided that there was no cause to hold a public hearing in regards to an ethics complaint that Carol Jacobs, president of Aquatic Center Inc. in McHenry, filed against Garrett County Commission Chairman Robert Gatto.

The ethics commission reviewed the minutes from the Feb. 18 Garrett County Commission public meeting and the Garrett County Public Ethics Ordinance. Upon completion of the review it was determined that the issues were clearly presented and framed and there was no cause for a public hearing, states the ethics commission opinion.

During the Feb. 18 meeting, County Attorney Gorman Getty presented the commissioners with three recommendations from the Garrett County Planning Commission for text amendments to the Deep Creek Watershed Zoning Ordinance. The commissioners were advised by professional staff that the text amendments were appropriate for consideration, according to the ethics commission opinion. The commissioners voted to approve the text amendments. Commissioner Gregan Crawford and Gatto voted in favor of the text amendments with Commissioner Jim Raley voting against.

Jacobs, along with five other marinas, filed for a judicial review of the commissioners’ decision to approve the adopted text amendments to the zoning ordinance, according to court documents.

More here.

Garrett County planners hold off on special exemption request

Elaine Blaisdell

Cumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — The Garrett County Planning Commission voted unanimously last week to table a discussion regarding a text amendment to the Deep Creek Watershed Zoning ordinance to include broader use of special exceptions within the watershed for recreational uses.

The discussion was tabled until a date to review the county’s comprehensive plan update is determined and until action is taken in regard to an ethics complaint that was recently filed against County Commission Chairman Robert Gatto, according to Deborah Carpenter, assistant director of the Office of Planning and Land Management.

During a Feb. 18 meeting, the county commissioners voted to send the matter of text amendments of the zoning ordinance back to the planning commission. Gatto and Commissioner Gregan Crawford voted in favor of the motion and Commissioner Jim Raley voted against it.

“Deep Creek Lake is a recreational area and given its nature is subject to competing demands,” reads a position statement made by Crawford and Gatto. “The public has expressed concern that there has not been sufficient public discussion and consideration of issues relating to recreational uses and the board is simply responding to that concern and are asking the planning commission for their input, nothing more.”

Also during that meeting, with Gatto recusing himself, Crawford made a motion to approve William Meagher’s request to add a new category of use for boat rentals including boat rides and/or boat tours as a separate service business and not offering any other services associated with a marina. Crawford’s motion died for lack of a second and therefore ended the pursuit and consideration of Meagher’s request for amendments to the zoning ordinance.

More here.

Mini-marina debate continues in Garrett County

Ethics complaint filed against commission chairman

Elaine Blaisdell

Cumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — Carol Jacobs, president of Aquatic Center Inc. in McHenry, has filed an ethics complaint with the Garrett County Ethics Commission regarding a potential conflict of interest involving Garrett County Commission Chairman Robert Gatto.

In July, the Garrett County Planning Commission recommended that county commissioners endorse William Meagher’s request to amend the Deep Creek Watershed Zoning Ordinance to add a new category of use for boat rentals not offering any services associated with a marina. The recommendation included certain modifications. Gatto recused himself from a county commission public hearing held in September based on the fact that his company, Gatto Electric, completed electrical work for Meagher, owner of Lakeside Creamery.

Gatto departed the public hearing and didn’t return until after the presentation and all public comments on the zoning amendments were heard, according to Jacobs.

During a county commission meeting Tuesday, Gatto also recused himself from a vote regarding Meagher’s request to make several amendments to the zoning ordinance to add a new category of use for boat rental including boat rides and/or boat tours as a separate service business and not offering any other services associated with a marina. Commissioner Gregan Crawford made a motion to approve Meagher’s request but it died for lack of a second, according to Monty Pagenhardt, county administrator.

“There is no pending proposal for any change to any ordinance,” said Pagenhardt.

However, the county commission did vote to approve the planning commission’s recommendation that several amendments be made to the Table of Dimensional Requirements for Principal Uses in the Deep Creek Watershed Zoning Ordinance, according to Pagenhardt.

Jacobs alleges that Gatto shouldn’t have recommended or voted to separate the amendments because they contain definitive language to further Meagher’s interests by allowing recreational uses in a shopping center, which were not allowed before.

The ethics complaint, which was filed online, was sent to Pagenhardt, who declined comment on the complaint. Pagenhardt will send a certified copy of the complaint via registered mail to the ethics commission and to Gatto.

The ethics commission is comprised of Thomas Janes, Wayne Wilt and Jack Riley, who was appointed by the county commissioners Tuesday.

Gatto will have 15 days to respond to the complaint and once the response is received a hearing will be held with the ethics commission to determine if there is cause to proceed further. Failure to respond to the notification of the ethics complaint form will have an unfavorable effect and could result in a default hearing with no input from the nonresponding party, according to the county’s website.

Gatto returned to the meeting Tuesday after recusing himself and voted along with the commissioners to send the matter back to the planning commission for consideration and review of context for potential use as a special exemption. Gatto and Crawford voted in favor of the motion and Jim Raley voted against it.

Jacobs also alleges that Gatto should not have participated in that vote.

More here.

Public hearing on wind farm in Deep Creek watershed delayed

From Staff Reports

Cumberland Times-News

DEEP CREEK LAKE — The public hearing scheduled for Wednesday for Messenger Limited Partnership’s request to the Garrett County Planning Commission to amend the Deep Creek watershed zoning ordinance to allow a wind farm in the rural resource zoning district has been rescheduled.

During a meeting Jan. 8, the planning commission voted unanimously to postpone the public hearing and rescheduleit for March 5 to allow the applicant more time to assemble information concerning the sound, wildlife impact and the appearance of the proposed wind turbines, according to minutes from the meeting. Planning commissioner Jeff Messenger recused himself from the vote as a landowner involved in the proposed project.

The commission also requested aesthetic views from different perspectives around the area and also raised questions about Maryland Public Service Commission requirements for an application for the wind turbines. During a commission meeting in December, Eric Robison, a member of the Deep Creek Lake Watershed Planning Steering Committee, questioned if Ogin (previously FloDesign) had applied to the PSC for a wind turbine certification for generating power. Lars Dorr, director of business development with Ogin Energy in Waltham, Mass., indicated he wasn’t aware of that requirement.

During the Jan. 8 meeting, Messenger stated that he will ensure that Ogin has the information to answer any questions that may arise at the public hearing. It is up to the developer to assume the risk of being able to comply with any state or federal regulations regarding wind turbines, according to Messenger.

Commission chairman Troy Ellington indicated that the Property Owners’ Association and other groups might have questions and concerns about the proposed turbines and the amendment to the zoning ordinance. The POA plans on attending the public hearing and presenting a paper opposing the proposed amendment, according to president Bob Hoffman.

More here.

Garrett commissioners OK Capital Improvement Program for schools

$582,400 earmarked for renovation project design at Southern Middle

Elaine Blaisdell

Cumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — The Garrett County commissioners unanimously approved the board of education’s 2015 Capital Improvement Program during their public meeting Tuesday and gave the board the green light to go ahead with the design phase of the Southern Middle School renovation project, according to Monty Pagenhardt, county administrator.

The $582,400 design funding for the project is included in the county’s fiscal 2014 budget.

“All projects on the CIP will be reviewed and approved as part of the fiscal year budget approval process,” said Pagenhardt.

Last year the commissioners voted to defer the funding of the project for a year and voiced concerns about being able to fund the project without a tax increase. There weren’t any changes to the county’s budget, ac-cording to Pagenhardt.

The project construction date for the renovation is still under consideration and has not been approved yet.

“At this time the county is not certain what actual revenue projections will be for forthcoming budget years although our financial model shows an improvement in expected revenue in the next several years,” said Pagenhardt.

More here.

Garrett commissioners seek liquor law changes

Elaine Blaisdell

Cumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — The Garrett County Commission on Wed-nesday voted to ask state legislators to approve a referendum for both on- and off-premise liquor sales and to extend enterprise zone tax credits for Strata Safety Products LLC through the state Department of Business and Economic Development, according to Monty Pagenhardt, county administrator.

The commissioners also agreed to support Garrett Cooperative Ministry’s request for a $99,500 bond to go toward a $1.1 million new facility and a legislative request to modify the county code of ordinances to add a member-at-large to the salary study commission.

The commission also approved the Liquor Control Board’s requests to remove obsolete language in the statutes regarding wineries, a refillable container and a beer festival. Chairman Robert Gatto voted in opposition to all the Liquor Control Board’s legislative requests, according to Pagenhardt.

Numerous establishments have on-premise sales for alcoholic beverages and can sell an alcoholic beverage with a meal on Sunday between 1 and 10 p.m., and the vote would allow other establishments to do the same, according to Debbe Owston, administrator to the Garrett County Liquor Control Board.

“There are several precincts or election districts that can’t do that and they compete with the other establishments that can,” said Owston during a public prelegislative meeting in December. “We have had 0 complaints about Sunday sales in a restaurant with a meal. This is the first time the liquor board has proposed a referendum vote.”

The off-premise sales would allow package stores to sell take-out alcoholic beverages from 1 to 10 p.m.

Several owners of service stations voiced their support of Sunday sales during the prelegislative meeting.

More here.

Garrett County commissioners vote to give school board $2.2 million

Elaine Blaisdell

Cumberland Times-News

OAKLAND — The Garrett County Commission voted unanimously on Tuesday to conditionally give the board of education $2.2 million for fiscal 2015.

The conditions require that the school board discontinue all plans to close schools in fiscal 2015 and that the Garrett County Public School System remain an entity participant in the Garrett County Employee Health Care Coalition.

“It has been a primary objective of budget deliberations to develop a comprehensive funding model that will allow the Garrett County Public School System to keep all schools open,” said Monty Pagenhardt, county administrator. “The board of county commissioners is now at a point that this objective can be met.”

“It sounds like we will be able to continue to nurture grade-school students in their community schools, as was always our intention,” said Cynthia Downton, school board president.

More here.